Teacher Feature...

Creation vs. Evolution
How Do Teachers Respond?

posted by Kevin on the
Science Teachers' Chatboard

I will be student teaching this fall in biology. I would like people's recommendations on how to deal with any issues that come up when discussing Darwin and the Theory of Evolution.


I teach 6th, so I do not know if the same will apply. I have had students ask me about the conflict with Darwin's theory and their religion. I talk to them about theories. I tell them that Darwin's theory is his interpretation of how life began. Many scientists believe it, while others are not so sure. It can be looked at as a theory of explanation, just as many religions have a theory of explanation. We, as teachers, are not advocating this theory, but instead, presenting it, just as we present all other information. In other words, we are not asking the student to throw out their religious beliefs and now believe in the theory of evolution. I hope this helps.


It's a difficult issue. I tell the kids (7th graders) that religion is a belief system. If you believe in creation, then by all means they must stick by their convictions.

However, evolution is a theory, something that has been supported by many hypothesis. It has not been DISPROVEN! We, as teachers, must teach truth found through the scientific method. Truth must be provable. All indications are is that evolution did occur and, as yet, the theory has passed every test.

Are we 100% certain that evolution did occur? No. However, every bit of evidence that supports it makes the probability that much higher. I'd say we are 97% sure.


I agree that the best way to launch the subject is to not be timid about bringing it up. I often start a lesson by asking what they already know (or think they know) about it. This is a great way to figure out who is especially sensitive or uncomfortable. It also helps to nab any (and there will be) misconceptions/misunderstandings. I always follow that up by explaining that my job is not to change their beliefs or even to challenge them but to provide information in the context of a science classroom. In science we can only work with things that are testable, measurable, etc. Spirituality is not testable or measurable and so it really does not belong in a scientific classroom.

You will find that they will ask you what you personally believe...I am often asked this. I simply state that how I feel or believe is also irrelevant--this is science and I do not have an opinion either way about scientific topics. (I ask them why nobody asked me what I believed about the circulatory system, genetics, or properties of diffusion.)

I have never had a parent question me although I did have another faculty member question the teaching of evolution. I simply deferred to the curriculum. I am mandated to teach an entire range of topics, one of which happens to be evolution. If they have an issue with that, they can address the board or the principal/dean, etc. I sort of look at it like "My hands are tied--nothing I can (or would) do!" If a parent were adamant about not wanting their child to be involved, I would absolutely cater to that. No battles! Make life easy! Best of luck to you!


I take the students through the discovery. I let them discover evolution. Start with variation...Darwin was a collector of Beetles, Moths, some were bigger, different markings, etc. He looked for a "good" specimen. Next I introduce the concept of genetic drift. Darwin bred pigeons, he had all sorts of unusual ones, he also knew that dogs had been bred into many breeds.

Finally, I take them onto the Beagle, Darwin saw this variety and this selection in nature, he saw that Turtles on the Galapagos Island were different between the islands. He saw the differences in the finches and the penny dropped, it was like his pigeons back home. What man did deliberately, was happening by accident in nature. That's all he said, he didn't talk about god or religion or anything else, he made an observation.

If I get a student who is particularly brainwashed, I've had students say that the devil put the fossils in the ground to trick us. I simple say its like a painting, you could say god created the painting, a scientist might say the painting is created by the laying down and mixing of pigments. One is talking about who, the other is talking about how. Maybe there is a God and this God created the means of evolution.


Some of these suggestions are great! I especially like Frank's ideas. I teach evolution to 7th graders in a school with a "Christ-centered atmosphere." One of the things I do is explain that in order to make a decision about what one believes, one would be wise to understand not only what they believe, but also the other beliefs out there. How can a Creationist argue against Evolution if they don't understand it? How can an Evolutionist argue against Creationism if they don't understand it? I tell my students that before they get into a debate about anything, they need to understand all sides in order to not sound ignorant. Understanding a particular point of view does not necessarily mean acceptance of it.
Me in NC


I tell my 8th grade and HS students that I am not trying to CONVINCE anyone of anything. If they believe in the Creation story, that is fine with me. If they believe in natural selection and evolution, that is fine with me too.

"I am not here to try to change anyone's mind... You do not have to personally believe in these ideas but you are responsible for understanding what they are and what evidence is used to support them."


First, evolution is not a theory, it just means change. Natural selection is the theory. As for scientific theories, so is the "quantum theory of the atom." However, try telling the inhabitants of Hiroshima and Nagasaki that it is "just a theory."


I'm glad you brought that up. You can use quantum theory to calculate what it takes to knock electrons out of specific orbitals. After all, this is the definition of ordinary chemistry by some standards. This "electronic dislocation" can induce a chemical change that may be difficult to predict by the conventional methods of physical chemistry. But in principle, it's still just ordinary chemistry, since the nucleus is not involved. On the other hand, involving the nucleus via slow neutron capture or other mechanism leads to other possibilities.

My point is that "evolution" and "natural selection" both take place within a framework that includes "background radiation". In the detonation of a Hiroshima- or Nagasaki- type device, the effects occur on a rather contracted time scale, compared to geologic time or however you measure biological change.

I'm fairly certain that most of the effects of the first atomic bombs were not explored in a lot of detail beforehand. But it should prove an interesting attempt to integrate such notions with Darwin.


My general sense of the whole debate is that the "public" has a superficial understanding of natural selection. I think you have to make a relationship of change in form with fossils AND modern creatures. There is ample evidence of microevolution in bird migratory paths and in the continuing genetic and physical divergence of the Galapagos finches. I bring out different kinds of peppers to show artificial selection. I usually introduce the topic following the discussions of DNA. Discuss various gene effects like codominance and incomplete dominance to show how even in genetically identical organisms- there is variation that may affect survival and reproduction.

My students were fascinated by the role of environment on genes. I point out how they are much taller and healthier with longer lifespans than their great-grandparents. That effect occurred too rapidly for genetic change to be the cause but it demonstrates that a gene may not reach its full expression in an environment. I showed them a film on the extraordinary variety of Cichlids in Africa and introduced the idea of adaptive radiation.

I believe the largest obstacle to understanding is vocabulary. Most people don't understand the terms properly. If you can reach a consensus on the meaning of the words "evolution" and "selection" you're on your way. Good luck.

Doc- I believe the Alamogordo detonation was thoroughly explored. The top physics people in America were deeply involved at a variety of sites. Richard Feynman described his role in the biographies. Oppenheimer and others have written extensively on it. Richard Rhodes also had an excellent book on the project in the 90's.
Laborer in the halls of learning

Browse through the latest posts from the Science Chatboard...


    What are the 4 classroom management styles briefly explain each of them? ›

    There are four styles of classroom management: authoritarian, authoritative, permissive, and indulgent. They range from the teacher having very strong control and less student involvement to the teacher having less control and more student involvement.

    What are the 3 E's lesson plan? ›

    I created lessons that would engage them at every point, and change things up every 10-15 minutes. Each time I approached a new unit, I kept the 3 E's in mind – Explore, Explain, & Engage.

    What are the 3 Ps of classroom management? ›

    The combined use of praise, proximity, and precorrection can: (1) reduce problem behaviors; (2) prevent the likelihood of recurring problem behaviors; (3) increase academic engagement time; and (4) increase the number of positive interactions between students and teachers.

    How do you plan classroom organization and management? ›

    8 Steps for Setting Up a Classroom Management Plan
    1. Set classroom expectations.
    2. Consider school policies when drafting a classroom management plan.
    3. Establish clear and consistent boundaries in your class.
    4. Use verbal and non-verbal reinforcement.
    5. Hand out a planned syllabus to your class.
    6. Know the students in the whole class.

    What are the 5 P's of classroom management? ›

    This is a simple but effective display for classroom expectations . It includes a poster for each of the 5 Ps . Prompt, polite, prepared, productive, and patient.

    What is the 5 E's learning plan? ›

    What are the 5Es? o The 5Es represent five stages of a sequence for teaching and learning: Engage, Explore, Explain, Extend (or Elaborate), and Evaluate.

    What are the 7 es in teaching? ›

    Learning Cycle 7E model is a learner-centered model. This model consists of stages of activities organized in such a way that students can master the competencies that must be achieved in learning by playing an active role. These stages are elicited, engage, explore, explain, elaborate, evaluate, and extend [7].

    What are the 7 E's in teaching? ›

    The 7E Instructional Strategy

    These phases, Elicit, Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, Evaluate and Extend, according to Gok et al. (2014), allows students to correct their misconceptions through exploration, and facilitate clarification by the teacher, and aided by explanations by the students themselves.

    What are the three C's of classroom discipline? ›

    As you consider some of your most challenging students or classes, think about your approach to classroom management through the lens of these three areas: connection, consistency, and compassion.

    What are the 4 basic elements of successful classroom management plans? ›

    According to researchers, classroom management is a core strategy for effective teaching, four components of classroom management were identified and analyzed, which included: rules and regulations, disciplinary interventions, teacher-student interactions, and mental sets.

    What are the three models of discipline? ›

    The Three Types: Preventive Discipline -- measures taken to preempt misbehavior by keeping students engaged. Supportive Discipline -- measures taken to assist students with self-control by helping them get back on task. Corrective Discipline -- measures taken when students are not following classroom or school rules.

    How can I quiet a class without yelling? ›

    10 Ways To Stop Yelling in the Classroom (and Still Get Students' Attention)
    1. Try a classic call-and-response or clap-back. ...
    2. Install a wireless doorbell. ...
    3. Teach them to respond to hand signals. ...
    4. Shut off the lights. ...
    5. Monitor noise levels with an app. ...
    6. Count down to quiet (or set a timer). ...
    7. Give them visual cues.
    Jun 20, 2019

    What is the most effective classroom arrangement? ›

    Rows/ Traditional Seating

    Students in the front rows have the highest rates of engagement while back rows tend to be less engaged. This style of seating can also be done on an angle, often called stadium seating. In this layout, the desks are in angled rows and may or may not touch.

    What is the best classroom management style? ›

    Authoritative classroom management style

    With an authoritative approach, student participation is expected both in class discussions and group work, but there are clear guidelines so that the class doesn't end up in chaos. Teachers value students' input, so they may work with the class to develop classroom rules.

    What are your classroom management styles? ›

    Choosing Your Classroom Management Style

    Now that we've discussed your teaching style and your classroom needs, let's put it altogether into a classroom management style. The four different types of classroom management are authoritarian, authoritative, permissive, and indulgent.

    What is the best classroom management styles? ›

    Authoritative classroom management style

    With an authoritative approach, student participation is expected both in class discussions and group work, but there are clear guidelines so that the class doesn't end up in chaos. Teachers value students' input, so they may work with the class to develop classroom rules.

    What are the four factors that affect classroom management? ›

    Classroom Management: 4 Key Factors to Consider
    • Effectual Teaching. A disorganized classroom without routines and expectations makes it difficult for the teacher to do her – his job. ...
    • Time issues. ...
    • Consistency. ...
    • Maintaining a healthy Learning Environment.
    Nov 11, 2019

    What are the methods of classroom management? ›

    The following classroom management strategies can be used to help maintain student focus and create student consistency around class expectations.
    • Understand your students. ...
    • Practice patience with Rational Detachment. ...
    • Set effective limits. ...
    • Keep to the schedule you set. ...
    • Be aware of the causes of behavior.
    Jan 4, 2021

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Laurine Ryan

    Last Updated:

    Views: 5953

    Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

    Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Laurine Ryan

    Birthday: 1994-12-23

    Address: Suite 751 871 Lissette Throughway, West Kittie, NH 41603

    Phone: +2366831109631

    Job: Sales Producer

    Hobby: Creative writing, Motor sports, Do it yourself, Skateboarding, Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Stand-up comedy

    Introduction: My name is Laurine Ryan, I am a adorable, fair, graceful, spotless, gorgeous, homely, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.